Best pizza places in 25 major cities

Pizza holds a special place in the heart of American cuisine, transcending regional and cultural boundaries to become a beloved staple across the nation. Its popularity is vast and undeniably widespread.

So just how much do we love our pizza? A study conducted by OnePoll and commissioned by Amazon Fresh found that Americans could eat about five slices of pizza in one sitting by themselves. A quarter love pizza so much, they would even consider serving it at their weddings. This love for “za” racked up nearly $47 billion dollars in 2022 sales.

What truly sets pizza apart is its remarkable versatility, evidenced by the unique array of styles found in cities throughout the country. In California, for example, pizza takes on a distinctive flair, boasting a thin crust topped with fresh local ingredients like arugula and Fresno chilies reflecting the state’s farm-to-table gastronomy. On the opposite coast, New York-style pies reign supreme with large, foldable slices and a classic combination of tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese. Meanwhile, Detroit-style pizza stands out with its square shape and thick, airy crust, crisped to perfection along the edges. And let’s not forget the iconic deep dish of Chicago, featuring a buttery thick crust filled to the brim with layers of cheese, a healthy variety of toppings, and chunky tomato sauce.

Amidst this diverse landscape, pizzerias have earned legendary status, drawing hungry visitors from far and wide. Places like Bestia in Los Angeles, famed for its wood-fired pizzas and standout dishes like slow-roasted lamb neck; Lombardi’s in New York’s Little Italy, supposedly responsible for the city’s distinctive style of pizza; and Pequod’s in Chicago, known for its carmelized crust, all serve as a testament to the influence pizza has had and continues to have in America.

So, where does one go for the best slice? To help you out, Stacker compiled a list of the best pizza restaurants in 25 major cities using data from Yelp. Businesses were selected using Yelp’s top 100 pizza spots list, which ranked restaurants using a number of factors, including the total volume and number of five-star reviews each business had by members of Yelp’s “Elite Squad.” The #1 restaurant in each city is included here, listed in alphabetical order.

Keep reading to see if your favorite spot made the list.

Note: The photos in this article are stock images and do not depict the specific restaurants listed or the dishes they serve.

Slice of pizza being pulled from a pan.
Canva

Anchorage: Moose’s Tooth

– Rating: 4.5 (3,387 reviews)
– Address: 3300 Old Seward Highway Anchorage, Alaska
Read more on Yelp

Clam gourmet pizza on tray.
Canva

Austin: Home Slice Pizza

– Rating: 4.4 (4,655 reviews)
– Address: 1415 South Congress Street Austin, Texas
Read more on Yelp

Pizza being pulled out of pizza oven.
Canva

Boston: The Salty Pig

– Rating: 4.2 (1,902 reviews)
– Address: 130 Dartmouth Street Boston, Massachusetts
Read more on Yelp

Closeup of Chicago-style deep dish pepperoni pizza.
Canva

Chicago: Pequod’s Pizza

– Rating: 3.9 (7,981 reviews)
– Address: 2207 North Clybourn Avenue Chicago, Illinois
Read more on Yelp

Margherita pizza being pulled out of pizza oven.
Canva

Denver: Osteria Marco

– Rating: 4.1 (1,815 reviews)
– Address: 1453 Larimer Street Denver, Colorado
Read more on Yelp

Supreme pizza loaded with toppings.
Canva

Honolulu: J. Dolan’s

– Rating: 4.2 (1,494 reviews)
– Address: 1147 Bethel Street Honolulu, Hawaii
Read more on Yelp

Sausage and pepperoni pizza on wooden surface.
Canva

Houston: Luigi’s Pizzeria

– Rating: 4.1 (1,216 reviews)
– Address: 3700 Almeda Road Houston, Texas
Read more on Yelp

Four-cheese pizza slice being pulled from a pie.
T.Dallas // Shutterstock

Las Vegas: Secret Pizza

– Rating: 4.2 (6,056 reviews)
– Address: 3708 Las Vegas Boulevard South Level 3 The Boulevard Tower Las Vegas, Nevada
Read more on Yelp

Veggie and pepperoni artisan pizza.
Canva

Los Angeles: Bestia

– Rating: 4.3 (7,710 reviews)
– Address: 2121 East 7th Plaza Los Angeles, California
Read more on Yelp

Sausage pizza being pulled out of the oven.
Canva

Miami: CRUST

– Rating: 4.6 (1,463 reviews)
– Address: 668 Northwest 5th Street Miami, Florida
Read more on Yelp

Artisan Margherita pizza.
Canva

Minneapolis: Surly Brewing

– Rating: 4.2 (1,358 reviews)
– Address: 520 Malcolm Avenue Southeast Minneapolis, Minnesota
Read more on Yelp

Closeup of supreme pizza with toppings.
Canva

New Haven: Modern Apizza

– Rating: 4.2 (1,683 reviews)
– Address: 874 State Street New Haven, CT
Read more on Yelp

Crispy pepperoni pizza slice.
Canva

New Orleans: Domenica

– Rating: 4.1 (2,167 reviews)
– Address: 123 Baronne Street New Orleans, Louisiana
Read more on Yelp

Margherita pizza on pizza tray.
Canva

New York City: Lombardi’s Pizza

– Rating: 3.8 (6,622 reviews)
– Address: 32 Spring Street New York, New York
Read more on Yelp

Chicken and onion pizza.
Canva

Orlando: Vivo Italian Kitchen

– Rating: 4.0 (1,271 reviews)
– Address: 6000 Universal Boulevard Orlando, Florida
Read more on Yelp

Mushroom pizza on tray.
Canva

Philadelphia: Barbuzzo

– Rating: 4.3 (3,269 reviews)
– Address: 110 S 13th Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Read more on Yelp

Pepperoni pizza closeup.
Canva

Phoenix: Cibo

– Rating: 4.4 (2,804 reviews)
– Address: 603 North 5th Ave Phoenix, Arizona
Read more on Yelp

Pizza with whole tomatoes.
Canva

Portland: Apizza Scholls

– Rating: 4.2 (1,775 reviews)
– Address: 4741 Southeast Hawthorne Boulevard Portland, Oregon
Read more on Yelp

Pizza with slices of tomato.
Canva

St. Louis: Anthonino’s Taverna

– Rating: 4.4 (1,421 reviews)
– Address: 2225 Macklind Avenue St. Louis, Missouri
Read more on Yelp

Truffle and salami artisan pizza.
Canva

San Antonio: Dough Pizzeria Napoletana

– Rating: 4.1 (1,849 reviews)
– Address: 6989 Blanco Road San Antonio, Texas
Read more on Yelp

Slices of tomato on pizza.
Canva

San Diego: CUCINA urbana

– Rating: 4.4 (4,674 reviews)
– Address: 505 Laurel Street San Diego, California
Read more on Yelp

Square slices of pizza with ham.
Canva

San Francisco: Golden Boy Pizza

– Rating: 4.4 (4,393 reviews)
– Address: 542 Green Street San Francisco, California
Read more on Yelp

Oval pepperoni pizza on pan.
Canva

Seattle: Serious Pie Downtown

– Rating: 4.1 (4,609 reviews)
– Address: 2001 4th Avenue Seattle, Washington
Read more on Yelp

Chicken, mushroom, and bacon pizza.
Canva

Tampa: Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza

– Rating: 4.3 (1,443 reviews)
– Address: 203 East Twiggs Street Tampa, Florida
Read more on Yelp

Artisan pizza with spinach.
Canva

Washington DC: il Canale

– Rating: 4.3 (4,634 reviews)
– Address: 1065 31st Street Washington D.C.
Read more on Yelp

Data reporting by Karim Noorani. Story editing by Carren Jao. Copy editing by Tim Bruns. Photo selection by Jaimie Etkin.

Provided by Stacker

Recently Played

Sweet Dreams (are Made Of This)Eurythmics
4:11am
Sweet EmotionAerosmith
4:06am
Tiny DancerElton John
4:00am
JumpVan Halen
3:56am
Edge Of SeventeenStevie Nicks
3:48am